Bay Shore Inn, Bay Shore ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

300 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, New York, United States of America, 11706

Bay Shore Inn, a 2-star hotel, features apartment-style suites with water views, private decks, and fully equipped kitchens. This Bay Shore hotel offers recreational activities including tennis, pickleball, and complimentary kayak rentals.

Rooms & Amenities

Rooms at Bay Shore Inn include amenities such as a king-sized bed, whirlpool tub, and free Wi-Fi. The hotel offers various two-bedroom suites, all featuring private decks with water views and full kitchens, making them ideal for families or group stays.

Dining & Nearby Options

Dining options nearby include Bright Bay Deli & Caterers, just 0.5 miles away, serving a variety of deli offerings. Guests can also explore local favorites like The Nightingale for prime rib, and enjoy traditional supper club meals either in-house or takeout to suite.

Leisure & Activities

Leisure facilities at Bay Shore Inn include an indoor pool, outdoor heated pool, and a campfire pit by the beach. Guests can engage in various activities such as shuffleboard and basketball, with complimentary kayaks and paddleboards available during summer months.

Services & Meetings

Services at Bay Shore Inn include guest laundry facilities and a fitness center for maintaining workouts. The hotel offers conference facilities accommodating up to 60 guests, suitable for meetings and events with local catering options.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Room

Max:

2 persons

17 m²

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Shower

Heating

room details

Check Prices

Queen Room

Max:

4 persons

19 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Heating

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

Queen Room

Max:

4 persons

19 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Heating

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A list of all available modes of transport

City Center

Bay Shore 1.7 mi

Airports

Republic (FRG) 8.8 mi

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 12.6 mi

Train

Central Islip 6.0 mi

Pinelawn 6.5 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Easy Parking Access

“The guest parking was incredibly convenient, with ample spaces that allowed us to park quickly and get on with our plans without any hassle.” view full review

Delicious & Varied

“The dining options were excellent, featuring a variety of tasty dishes that suited all our preferences and made every meal enjoyable.” view full review

Great Meeting Spaces

“The meeting facilities were perfect for our needs, equipped with modern technology that made our presentations seamless and professional.” view full review

Relaxing Spa Experience

“The spa provided an excellent escape with various treatments that left me feeling rejuvenated and relaxed, enhancing my overall stay.” view full review

General

Free Wi-Fi
Parking
24-hour reception

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

300 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, New York, United States of America, 11706

Map view

300 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, New York, United States of America, 11706

City landmarks

Church

Calvary Baptist Church Bay Shore

1.0 mi

Calvary Baptist Church

1.0 mi

Wohseepee Park Cabin

1.0 mi

Love & Mercy Fellowship

1.2 mi

Montauk Highway & Manor Lane West Bay Shore

Sagtikos Manor

1.7 mi

Montauk Highway

Gardiner County Park

1.5 mi

Church

Our Lady of Lourdes Parish

1.4 mi

Church

First Baptist Church Of Bay Shore

1.3 mi

Jewish Center of Bay Shore

1.4 mi

Church

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

1.4 mi

Church

RCCG- Redeemed Christian Church Of GOD

1.4 mi

Gospel Lighthouse Pentecostal Church

1.5 mi

Saint Patrick's Roman Catholic Church

1.5 mi

First Congregational Church of Bay Shore

1.7 mi

Saint Georges University School

1.5 mi

Saint Lukes Lutheran Church

1.6 mi

First Church of Christ Scientist

1.6 mi

Mall

Westfield South Shore

1.7 mi

Church

The United Methodist Church of Bay Shore

1.7 mi

Guggenheim Lakes

1.7 mi

Loews Bay Shore Twin

1.7 mi

Unity Greater Highway Church

1.8 mi

Museums

The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia

1.8 mi

Westminster United Presbyterian Church

1.8 mi

Church

St Peter's By-the-Sea Episcopal Church

1.8 mi

Farm

Brightwaters Farms

1.9 mi

Sundance

1.9 mi

Kingdom Hall of Jehovah's Witnesses

1.9 mi

Restaurants

Bright Bay Deli & Caterers

1100 ft

180 Howells Rd

Peter Pan Diner

1200 ft

999 Sunrise Hwy

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

84%

liked the hotel and would stay again

Clean rooms

Friendly staff

Limited dining

Average facilities

8.4/10

Great

Rooms

8.7

Location

9.3

Service

8.7

Dining

7.7

Luther

United States of America, March 2024

9.2/10

I absolutely loved my stay at this hotel! The location is superb, close to a shopping center and the Forum, in a relatively safe area and near everything. The rooms were spacious and modern, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator, making them super convenient. The service was top-notch, and housekeeping kept everything perfectly clean. However, the dining options were a bit limited, but the hot dishes available were delicious. The facilities were fantastic, offering everything I needed for a comfortable stay.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious and modern, furnished with a microwave and refrigerator.

Service

9.0

The service was excellent, and the housekeeping was spot on.

Location

10.0

The hotel's location was perfect, close to a shopping center, the Forum, in a relatively safe area, and near everything.

Dining

8.0

The dining experience was enjoyable, especially the hot dishes served.

Facilities

10.0

The facilities were fantastic, catering to all my needs.

John

United States of America, January 2024

9.0/10

I loved my stay at this hotel! The location is perfect, close to everything on Long Island and in a relatively safe area. The rooms were clean and comfortable, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator. The service was exceptional, and the housekeeping was top-notch. The dining experience was delightful, especially with the organic products. The hotel's facilities were impressive, making my stay even more enjoyable.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were clean and comfortable, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator.

Service

9.0

The service was exceptional, and the housekeeping was top-notch.

Location

10.0

The hotel is conveniently located close to everything on Long Island and in a relatively safe area. It's also near a shopping center.

Dining

8.0

The dining experience was delightful, especially with the organic products.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel's facilities were impressive, making my stay even more enjoyable.

Wendy

United States of America, November 2023

8.2/10

The hotel is located on Long Island, close to a shopping center, in a relatively safe area. The rooms come with a microwave and refrigerator, offering convenience. The service was satisfactory, although housekeeping could be more attentive. The dining options were decent, especially the sushi. The facilities are modern and well-maintained, providing a comfortable stay at a reasonable price.

Rooms

8.0

The rooms were equipped with a microwave and refrigerator, adding to the convenience.

Service

7.0

The service was good overall, but housekeeping could be more attentive.

Location

9.0

The location on Long Island, close to a shopping center, in a relatively safe area, made it convenient for exploring the area.

Dining

8.0

The dining experience was enjoyable, especially the sushi.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel facilities were modern and well-maintained, enhancing the overall stay.

Chris

United States of America, August 2023

7.8/10

I had a pleasant stay at this hotel. The location is convenient, close to a shopping center in a relatively safe area on Long Island. The rooms were clean and comfortable, but the dining options were limited. The staff provided good service, and the facilities were satisfactory. The value for money was reasonable, considering the amenities provided.

Rooms

8.0

The rooms were clean and comfortable, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator.

Service

9.0

The staff was friendly and accommodating, and the housekeeping service was attentive.

Location

9.0

The hotel is conveniently located on Long Island, close to a shopping center in a safe area.

Dining

6.0

The dining experience was average, with limited options for takeaway food.

Facilities

7.0

The facilities were decent, but nothing extraordinary.

Clean rooms

Limited dining

Benjamin

United States of America, June 2023

8.6/10

I had a pleasant stay at this hotel. The rooms were clean and well-equipped with a microwave and refrigerator, offering great value for money. The service was excellent, especially the housekeeping. The location is convenient, being close to a shopping center in a safe area on Long Island. The dining experience, especially the cream cakes, was delightful. The facilities provided added to the overall positive experience.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were clean and equipped with a microwave and refrigerator, providing excellent value for money.

Service

9.0

The service was top-notch, with excellent housekeeping.

Location

8.0

The hotel's location on Long Island near a shopping center in a safe area was very convenient.

Dining

8.0

The dining experience, especially the cream cakes, was delightful.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities provided complemented my stay perfectly.

George

United States of America, May 2023

8.6/10

I had a wonderful stay at this hotel. The location is excellent, close to everything on Long Island and to the Forum, in a relatively safe area. The rooms were spacious and modern, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator. The service was top-notch, especially the housekeeping. However, the food at the restaurant was extraordinary, and the facilities were lacking a bit.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious and modern, equipped with a microwave and refrigerator.

Service

9.0

The service was top-notch, especially the housekeeping.

Location

10.0

The location is excellent, close to everything on Long Island and to the Forum, in a relatively safe area.

Dining

8.0

The food at the restaurant was extraordinary.